In July 2025, Maui County Council’s Housing and Land Use Committee convened to discuss Bill 9—a highly debated proposal to phase out approximately 7,000 short-term vacation rentals (STRs) in apartment-zoned districts. The move is part of a broader strategy to ease the island’s housing shortage, a crisis magnified by the 2023 Lahaina wildfires.

Key Points of Bill 9
- Focus on Apartment-Zoned Rentals: Bill 9 targets STRs located in apartment-zoned areas that have operated under a 2001 legal opinion known locally as the “Minatoya List.”
- Timeline for Phase-Out: The bill initially set the deadline for July 2025 in West Maui and January 2026 in South Maui. An amended version now allows a three-year transition period.
- Exemptions: Timeshare units are expected to be exempt from this phase-out, though further clarification may come during future deliberations.
Why the Bill Matters
Supporters say:
- More Housing for Locals: Thousands of vacation rentals could be converted into long-term housing for residents.
- Community Stability: Removing transient visitors from residential buildings could enhance the quality of life and community cohesion.
Critics argue:
- Economic Fallout: STRs significantly contribute to the island’s economy through jobs and tourism taxes. Their loss may lead to reduced income for both local workers and government coffers.
- Property Rights Concerns: Many property owners legally purchased and operated these rentals under county approval, raising legal questions about compensation and fairness.
Legal and Financial Considerations
The bill is expected to face legal challenges. Critics argue that phasing out STRs could violate property rights, particularly under the U.S. Constitution’s Fifth Amendment, which protects against unlawful seizure of private property without compensation.

What’s Next?
After a lengthy public hearing and a closed executive session, the Housing and Land Use Committee paused its discussion of the bill. Deliberations will resume on July 23, 2025.
FAQs
Q1: What is the “Minatoya List”?
A: It refers to a legal opinion issued in 2001 allowing certain apartment-zoned properties to operate as STRs.
Q2: How could this bill affect Maui’s economy?
A: The proposed phase-out could impact tourism-related jobs, reduce hotel taxes, and lower economic output tied to visitor spending.
Q3: Can owners convert their units or apply for rezoning?
A: Yes, the proposed three-year transition period allows time to either convert STRs to long-term rentals or apply for rezoning.
Q4: Are there any properties that won’t be affected?
A: Timeshare units are expected to be exempt from the phase-out under current provisions.
Q5: When will the next decision be made?
A: The committee is scheduled to reconvene and continue deliberations on July 23, 2025.
Maui’s approach to managing tourism and housing demand could become a model—or a cautionary tale—for other destinations facing similar challenges. The final outcome of Bill 9 will likely have lasting effects on local housing access, tourism revenue, and property law in Hawai‘i.

Sources Maui Now
