For decades, the tourism industry has celebrated a familiar set of victories: more international arrivals, fuller hotels, busier airports and record-breaking visitor spending. But what if a destination welcomes millions of tourists while its residents struggle with rising housing costs, its natural environment deteriorates and local workers see few long-term benefits?
That is the uncomfortable question behind a new approach to measuring tourism success.
The World Travel & Tourism Council (WTTC), working with Oxford Economics, has introduced its Power, Efficiency and Opportunity (PEO) Indices, a framework designed to assess tourism across 184 economies. Instead of focusing mainly on how many people visit a country, the indices examine the sector’s economic scale, environmental performance and contribution to employment.
The idea is straightforward but important: tourism should not simply grow. It should create lasting value without placing unsustainable pressure on the places and communities that make travel attractive in the first place.

Why the Tourism Industry Needs a New Measure of Success
For years, international arrivals were among the most visible indicators of a successful tourism strategy. Governments competed to attract more visitors, airlines expanded routes, hotels increased capacity and destinations promoted themselves to global audiences.
Visitor numbers are useful. They help governments understand demand, plan infrastructure and estimate economic activity. However, they reveal only part of the picture.
A destination can record a dramatic increase in arrivals while facing serious problems:
- Overtourism: Popular neighbourhoods, beaches and historic sites become overcrowded.
- Housing pressure: Short-term holiday rentals can reduce the supply of homes available to local residents.
- Environmental damage: More flights, transport, waste and resource consumption can increase tourism’s ecological footprint.
- Unequal economic benefits: Large international hotel groups and travel companies may capture a substantial share of tourism revenue.
- Seasonal employment: Workers may find jobs during peak months but struggle with unstable income during the rest of the year.
- Infrastructure strain: Roads, public transport, water systems and waste services may struggle to cope with visitor demand.
These challenges expose a weakness in traditional tourism measurements. A record number of arrivals does not necessarily mean a destination is becoming more prosperous, sustainable or liveable.
The new WTTC framework attempts to broaden that definition by examining not only the size of tourism, but also how efficiently it operates and who benefits from it.
The Three Pillars of the New Tourism Index
The PEO framework consists of three separate indices. Each measures a different aspect of tourism performance, and the results are intended to be considered together rather than treated as one simple league table.
1. Power Index: Which Countries Have the Biggest Tourism Economies?
The Power Index measures the economic scale and influence of tourism through three main indicators:
- Tourism’s contribution to gross domestic product (GDP).
- The number of people employed in tourism-related activities.
- Investment in the travel and tourism sector.
The leading countries are:
| Rank | Country |
|---|---|
| 1 | United States |
| 2 | China |
| 3 | India |
| 4 | Germany |
| 5 | France |
| 6 | United Kingdom |
| 7 | Japan |
| 8 | Mexico |
| 9 | Spain |
| 10 | Saudi Arabia |
The United States leads the ranking, reflecting the enormous scale of its tourism economy. China and India follow, supported by large domestic markets, growing international travel demand and substantial investment.
The findings also reveal how concentrated tourism’s economic power remains. According to WTTC, the 20 highest-performing economies accounted for 81% of global travel and tourism GDP in 2024.
However, economic size does not automatically translate into sustainable tourism. A country can generate enormous tourism revenue while struggling with pollution, overcrowding or unequal employment opportunities. That is why the other two indices are important.
2. Environmental Efficiency Index: Which Destinations Generate More Value With Less Environmental Pressure?
Tourism depends heavily on natural resources. Visitors need clean water, reliable energy, transport networks and attractive landscapes. Yet the industry can also contribute to greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, waste and pressure on ecosystems.
The Environmental Efficiency Index examines the environmental footprint of tourism relative to the economic activity it generates.
Its indicators include:
- Greenhouse gas emissions.
- Use of low-carbon energy.
- Water consumption.
- Air pollution.
- Materials use.
Two countries stand out in the initial results:
- Sweden ranks first among high-income economies.
- Costa Rica leads among upper-middle-income economies.
Their positions demonstrate that environmental performance is not limited to wealthy countries. Different economies can make progress through clean-energy investment, resource management and policies that protect natural assets.
The WTTC findings also report improvements between 2019 and 2024. The global Environmental Efficiency score increased by 2.3 points, with the low-carbon energy component improving by 6.7 points and greenhouse gas intensity by 3.9 points.
These are encouraging trends, but they should not be mistaken for proof that tourism has become environmentally harmless. Efficiency measures how much environmental pressure is associated with economic activity; it does not necessarily mean the total environmental footprint is falling. If visitor numbers increase rapidly, total emissions and resource consumption could still rise.
3. Opportunity Index: Does Tourism Create Jobs and Improve People’s Lives?
Tourism is often described as an important source of employment, particularly in countries where hotels, restaurants, transport operators and tour companies form a major part of the economy.
But the number of jobs alone does not tell the whole story. The quality, accessibility and distribution of employment also matter.
The Opportunity Index examines tourism’s contribution to social development through:
- Tourism’s share of total employment.
- Employment growth.
- Youth employment.
- Female employment.
The leading countries are divided by income group:
| Income group | Leading country |
|---|---|
| High-income economies | Croatia |
| Upper-middle-income economies | Maldives |
| Lower-middle-income economies | El Salvador |
| Low-income economies | The Gambia |
The results highlight tourism’s importance in countries where the industry supports a substantial proportion of national employment.
The Maldives, Grenada and Belize are examples of destinations where tourism provides a significant share of jobs.
This is particularly relevant for women and young people, who may find opportunities in hospitality, food services, travel operations, cultural tourism and small businesses. However, the long-term value of these jobs also depends on wages, working conditions, training, career progression and employment security.
What the Rankings Tell Us About the Future of Tourism
The most important lesson from the PEO Indices is that a country does not need to lead every category to be considered successful.
A major tourism economy may generate enormous revenue but have room to improve its environmental performance. A smaller destination may generate less overall economic activity but perform strongly in employment opportunities or resource efficiency.
This makes the framework more useful than a single ranking based only on visitor numbers.
Consider three different examples:
- The United States has enormous tourism economic power, but its scale alone does not establish that every destination within the country is environmentally sustainable.
- Costa Rica demonstrates that a destination can gain recognition for environmental efficiency without belonging to the world’s largest tourism economies.
- The Maldives illustrates how tourism can be central to employment and economic opportunity, while also making the country particularly dependent on the industry’s continued health.
The framework encourages governments to identify where their strengths lie and where investment or policy changes could produce the greatest improvements.

Tourism Success Is About More Than One Index
The new WTTC framework is part of a wider international shift towards measuring tourism development through more comprehensive indicators.
One important comparison is the World Economic Forum’s Travel & Tourism Development Index (TTDI) 2026. Although both initiatives look beyond visitor arrivals, they serve different purposes.
The WTTC PEO Indices assess tourism’s economic power, environmental efficiency and employment opportunities across 184 economies. The WEF’s TTDI examines the conditions that enable tourism to develop sustainably and withstand disruption across 110 economies.
The TTDI uses 17 pillars and 102 individual indicators, grouped into five broad dimensions:
- Enabling environment, including safety, health, labour and business conditions.
- Tourism policy and enabling conditions, including government priorities and openness to travel.
- Infrastructure and services, including air transport and tourism facilities.
- Tourism resources, including natural, cultural and business-related attractions.
- Sustainability, including environmental and socioeconomic impacts.
In its 2026 edition, Japan ranked first overall, followed by the United States and Spain. The report also found that 92% of the 110 economies improved their TTDI scores between 2024 and 2026.
The distinction matters. A country may have excellent airports, hotels and visitor attractions but still struggle to distribute tourism benefits fairly. Another may have strong employment outcomes but lack the transport infrastructure needed to attract more visitors.
Together, these frameworks provide a broader picture of the industry’s performance.
Why Overtourism Has Become a Major Test for Destinations
One of the biggest reasons tourism measurement needs to change is the growing problem of overtourism.
Popular destinations such as Venice, Barcelona, Amsterdam and parts of Japan have faced difficult questions about how many visitors their communities and infrastructure can reasonably accommodate.
Large visitor numbers can support local restaurants, hotels, shops and cultural attractions. However, excessive concentration can also create problems:
- Residents face competition for housing.
- Public transport becomes crowded.
- Historic streets and attractions experience physical pressure.
- Waste and water systems face additional demand.
- Local shops may be replaced by businesses serving short-term visitors.
- Residents can become increasingly frustrated with the effects of tourism.
The problem is not necessarily that too many people visit a country. It is often that too many visitors arrive in the same place, at the same time, and use the same limited infrastructure.
The WEF’s 2026 analysis highlights the importance of spreading tourism demand across different regions and seasons. Japan provides an example: its efforts to diversify visitor markets and encourage travel beyond major urban centres have helped strengthen its tourism resilience. The report notes that international visitor nights in regional areas grew by 14.1% year on year in October 2025, compared with a 0.8% decline in the country’s three major urban areas.
This is a useful reminder that tourism growth does not always require building more capacity in already crowded destinations. Sometimes, better distribution is the smarter strategy.
Can Tourism Become More Environmentally Sustainable?
Environmental sustainability is one of the hardest challenges facing the travel industry.
Air travel, cruise ships, road transport and accommodation all consume energy. Tourism can also increase demand for freshwater, food, construction materials and waste management.
Improving environmental efficiency requires action across the entire tourism supply chain.
Airlines and transport operators can invest in more efficient aircraft, cleaner fuels where viable, better route planning and lower-emission ground transport.
Hotels and resorts can reduce energy consumption, improve insulation, install renewable energy systems, manage water use and limit unnecessary waste.
Governments can invest in public transport, environmental protection, wastewater treatment and more sustainable urban planning.
Tourists can contribute by choosing lower-impact transport where practical, staying longer rather than taking multiple short trips, supporting local businesses and respecting protected natural areas.
There is no single solution. The environmental impact of a holiday depends on distance travelled, transport choices, accommodation, activities and the destination’s ability to manage visitors responsibly.
The PEO framework provides a way to compare environmental performance, but meaningful progress ultimately requires changes in investment, infrastructure and everyday business practices.
Tourism Employment: Are Local Communities Receiving the Benefits?
Tourism can create opportunities for people who might otherwise have limited access to formal employment.
Hotels need receptionists, cleaners, cooks and managers. Restaurants employ chefs and service staff. Tour operators need guides and drivers. Airports, attractions and transport companies create additional jobs.
However, the benefits are not always distributed evenly.
Some destinations rely heavily on seasonal workers who face unpredictable income and limited job security. In other places, senior management positions are filled by people recruited from outside the local community, while residents remain concentrated in lower-paid roles.
The Opportunity Index draws attention to employment growth, youth participation and female employment. These are important indicators, but they are only part of a wider discussion about decent work.
For tourism to create lasting social value, governments and businesses should also consider:
- Fair wages and reliable working conditions.
- Access to vocational education and professional training.
- Opportunities for local people to move into management.
- Support for locally owned businesses.
- Affordable housing for tourism workers.
- Protection against discrimination and unsafe workplaces.
Oman’s results offer an interesting example. WTTC reported that women held 28% of tourism jobs in the country, compared with 18% across the Middle East. Young people accounted for 13% of tourism employment, compared with less than 9% across the wider Omani economy.
These figures illustrate how tourism can contribute to broader workforce development when employment opportunities are actively supported.
The Hidden Challenge: Measuring Tourism Fairly
Although the PEO Indices represent an important development, no index can capture every dimension of tourism success.
There are several reasons why the results should be interpreted carefully.
First, economic scale can overshadow local realities. A large country may perform strongly because of its enormous tourism economy, even though some individual destinations within it face serious problems.
Second, efficiency is not the same as total environmental impact. A destination may generate more economic value for each unit of emissions while still increasing its overall emissions as tourism expands.
Third, employment figures do not automatically measure job quality. More jobs do not necessarily mean better wages, safer working conditions or greater financial security.
Fourth, national averages can conceal regional inequality. A country may benefit economically from tourism while certain communities receive very little of the revenue or experience most of the environmental pressure.
Finally, data availability and comparability matter. Countries collect information differently, and environmental or employment statistics may not always cover the same periods. Rankings should therefore be treated as tools for analysis rather than definitive judgments about the quality of a destination.
The WEF also cautions that its own TTDI results reflect the latest available data collected by May 2026, meaning some indicators may not capture the most recent developments.
For these reasons, governments should combine international rankings with local data, resident feedback, independent environmental assessments and transparent reporting.
What Governments and Tourism Businesses Should Do Next
The new approach will only make a difference if it influences real decisions.
For governments, the first step should be to move beyond arrival targets when designing tourism strategies. Visitor numbers should be considered alongside employment quality, environmental performance, infrastructure capacity and the distribution of economic benefits.
Tourism authorities can also encourage visitors to explore less crowded regions, travel outside peak seasons and support local enterprises.
Businesses should treat sustainability and workforce development as long-term investments rather than marketing exercises. Energy efficiency, fair employment practices, local purchasing and responsible waste management can strengthen both community relationships and business resilience.
The WEF’s 2026 report identifies several additional priorities for destinations operating in an increasingly uncertain world. These include diversifying visitor markets, protecting transport and digital access, competing on value rather than simply low prices, using digital innovation and improving the ability to respond to disruption.
Tourism destinations also need to prepare for climate-related disruption, geopolitical instability, changing consumer preferences and labour shortages. A successful destination is not simply one that attracts visitors during good times. It is one that can continue operating, protect its communities and recover when circumstances change.
A New Definition of Tourism Success
The launch of the WTTC Power, Efficiency and Opportunity Indices signals a meaningful change in how the tourism industry thinks about growth.
For too long, record arrivals and rising visitor spending have dominated conversations about success. Those figures remain important, but they cannot explain whether tourism is improving people’s lives, protecting natural resources or building resilient local economies.
The new framework offers a broader perspective by examining economic strength, environmental efficiency and employment opportunities together.
There is still a long way to go. Rankings must be supported by transparent data, meaningful local measurements and policies that turn good performance into real improvements for communities.
Ultimately, the best tourism destination is not necessarily the one that welcomes the most visitors. It is the one where travellers enjoy memorable experiences, local people share in the benefits, businesses can prosper and the environment remains healthy for future generations.
That may be a more difficult definition of success, but it is also a far more meaningful one.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the WTTC Power, Efficiency and Opportunity Index?
The Power, Efficiency and Opportunity (PEO) Indices are a tourism measurement framework developed by the World Travel & Tourism Council and Oxford Economics. They assess 184 economies across three areas: tourism’s economic importance, its environmental efficiency and its contribution to employment opportunities.
2. Which country ranks first in the WTTC Power Index?
The United States ranks first, followed by China and India. The ranking considers tourism’s economic contribution, employment footprint and investment rather than simply the number of international visitors.
3. Which countries lead the Environmental Efficiency Index?
Sweden ranks first among high-income economies, while Costa Rica leads among upper-middle-income economies. The index considers environmental indicators such as greenhouse gas emissions, low-carbon energy use, water consumption, air pollution and materials use.
4. Which countries perform best in tourism employment opportunities?
The Opportunity Index leaders are Croatia among high-income economies, the Maldives among upper-middle-income economies, El Salvador among lower-middle-income economies and The Gambia among low-income economies. The index considers employment share, employment growth, youth employment and female employment.
5. Why is measuring tourism success beyond visitor numbers important?
Visitor numbers do not show whether tourism benefits local residents, creates quality jobs or protects the environment. A broader measurement approach helps governments identify problems such as overtourism, housing pressure, environmental damage and unequal economic benefits. It also encourages destinations to pursue more balanced and sustainable growth.

Sources Euro News

