Beyond the Tourist Trail: Why Travelers Are Choosing House-Sitting in Honolulu, Miami and New York

Charming wooden cabin in São Bento do Sapucaí, Brazil with a couple enjoying a picnic.

The New Way to Travel: Live Like a Local Instead of Staying Like a Tourist

The most memorable way to experience a destination may not involve checking into a hotel at all. Increasingly, some travelers are discovering a different way to explore expensive, popular cities: staying in someone else’s home, caring for their pets and temporarily becoming part of the neighbourhood.

A November 7, 2026, New York Post report highlights this growing interest in house-sitting, with Honolulu, Miami and Manhattan emerging as particularly desirable destinations. The appeal is about more than saving money. Longer stays, everyday routines and the chance to experience a place beyond its familiar tourist attractions are changing how some people think about travel.

The trend reflects a wider shift in tourism. Rather than rushing between famous landmarks, some visitors want to shop at neighbourhood markets, walk the same streets every morning, discover independent restaurants and experience the rhythms of ordinary life.

But house-sitting is not a free holiday, and a high ranking on a platform’s list does not necessarily mean a destination is undiscovered or inexpensive. Understanding the trend requires looking at the data, the practical arrangements and the impact tourism can have on the communities welcoming visitors.

The Research Behind America’s Most Popular House-Sitting Destinations

The rankings highlighted by the New York Post are based on research by TrustedHousesitters, a platform connecting homeowners who need pet care with people willing to look after their homes and animals while they are away.

Published on October 27, 2026, the company’s report examined more than four years of internal platform data, comparing house-sitting activity across 50 US destinations.

Its experience index considered six equally weighted measures:

  • Average applications received per house sit within seven days.
  • Year-on-year growth in applications.
  • The percentage of sitters travelling from outside the destination’s state.
  • The percentage of repeat sitters.
  • Average length of stays.
  • The percentage of listings reaching the platform’s five-application limit within seven days.

The results produced the following leading destinations:

DestinationExperience score
Honolulu, Hawaii79.8
Miami, Florida76.9
Manhattan, New York75.2
Brooklyn, New YorkAmong the leading destinations
Fort Lauderdale, FloridaAmong the leading destinations

The important qualification is that these figures measure demand and engagement among the platform’s members. They are not a national survey of every American traveler, nor a direct measurement of overall tourism popularity.

Nevertheless, the results offer an interesting snapshot of the places where house-sitting travelers are particularly keen to spend time.

1. Honolulu: Island Living Takes the Top Spot

Honolulu claimed first place with an experience score of 79.8 out of 100.

The city averaged seven applications per house sit within seven days, the highest figure in the study. Almost four in five listings, or 78.9%, reached the platform’s five-application limit during that period.

The destination’s appeal extends well beyond Hawaii’s own residents. Approximately 74.4% of sitters came from outside the state, while the average house-sitting stay lasted 12.3 days, the longest among the destinations examined.

These figures suggest that visitors are not simply looking for a quick beach holiday. Many are interested in spending enough time on the island to develop a temporary routine.

Why Honolulu attracts longer stays

Honolulu combines tropical scenery with the practical conveniences of a major American city. Visitors can enjoy beaches, restaurants, shopping, cultural attractions and outdoor activities without giving up access to everyday urban services.

The appeal is also closely connected to Hawaii’s distinctive environment and lifestyle.

Visitors can explore Waikīkī, hike in the surrounding mountains, discover local food traditions and spend time in neighbourhoods beyond the main resort areas. The island’s climate makes outdoor activities possible throughout much of the year, although weather conditions and seasonal differences still matter.

A longer stay gives travelers more opportunities to experience places such as:

  • Waikīkī: Famous for its beach, surfing culture, restaurants and shopping.
  • Kakaʻako: A lively urban district known for public art, independent businesses and food options.
  • Kaimukī: A residential neighbourhood with local restaurants, cafés and a less resort-oriented atmosphere.
  • North Shore: Known for its coastal communities, surf culture and dramatic beaches.
  • Manoa: A green residential valley with access to hiking and outdoor scenery.

House-sitting can make these experiences feel more natural because visitors are not necessarily following a hotel-based schedule.

The reality behind Hawaii’s popularity

There is another side to Honolulu’s appeal: Hawaii is an expensive place to live and visit.

Accommodation, transportation, food and everyday services can place considerable pressure on travel budgets. A house sit may reduce accommodation expenses, but it does not eliminate the cost of flights, groceries, transport, activities or other daily needs.

Tourism also creates challenges for local communities.

The Hawaiʻi Tourism Authority’s Oʻahu Destination Management Action Plan for 2026–2028 highlights the need to protect natural and cultural resources while improving residents’ quality of life. It identifies congestion, visitor education, community participation and the management of heavily visited areas as important priorities.

In 2025, Oʻahu recorded approximately 5.68 million visitor arrivals and $9.42 billion in visitor expenditure, according to preliminary figures. Arrivals declined by about 2% compared with 2024, while spending increased by 5.3%.

The same authority reported that 60% of surveyed Oʻahu residents believed tourism had brought more benefits than problems, while only 32% agreed that they had a voice in tourism development decisions.

This highlights an important point: authentic travel should involve respect for the people who actually live in a destination, not simply finding a cheaper way to enjoy its attractions.

2. Miami: Sunshine, Food and Rapidly Growing Demand

Miami ranked second with a score of 76.9 out of 100.

It recorded the strongest year-on-year increase in house-sitting applications among the leading destinations, with demand rising 43.2%.

The city averaged 5.9 applications per house sit within seven days, and 78.8% of listings reached the platform’s five-application limit during that period.

Miami’s combination of warm weather, beaches, food and cultural diversity helps explain its popularity.

More than beaches and nightlife

Miami is often associated with luxury hotels, nightlife, celebrity appearances and glamorous waterfront properties. But the city has a much broader identity.

Its cultural character has been shaped by decades of migration from Cuba, the Caribbean, Central America and South America. Spanish is widely spoken, and the city’s food, music, architecture and neighbourhood traditions reflect this diversity.

Visitors who stay longer can explore areas such as:

  • Little Havana: A centre of Cuban-American culture, with cafés, bakeries, music and traditional food.
  • Wynwood: Known for street art, galleries, creative businesses and restaurants.
  • Coconut Grove: A leafy neighbourhood with waterfront parks, cafés and a relaxed atmosphere.
  • Little Haiti: An important centre of Haitian culture, art and community life.
  • Coral Gables: Recognised for its Mediterranean-inspired architecture, shopping streets and historic character.

A house sit in one of these neighbourhoods can provide a different perspective from staying in a resort or a hotel close to the beach.

Instead of treating Miami as a collection of attractions, visitors may begin to experience it through ordinary routines: walking a dog in the morning, buying coffee nearby, visiting local markets and discovering restaurants that are not necessarily advertised to tourists.

The affordability contradiction

Miami’s popularity comes with a financial complication.

The TrustedHousesitters report found that Miami and Fort Lauderdale had overall price levels approximately 14.2% above the US average, using 2024 Regional Price Parities from the US Bureau of Economic Analysis.

This means that avoiding a hotel bill does not automatically make a Miami stay inexpensive.

Food, transport, entertainment and other expenses can still add up quickly. Visitors may also need to consider the cost of renting a vehicle or travelling between neighbourhoods.

House-sitting can therefore be particularly attractive to people who want to spend more time in Miami without paying for accommodation every night.

However, travelers should compare the total cost of a house-sitting arrangement with alternative accommodation rather than assuming that it will always be the cheapest option.

3. Manhattan: Experience New York Beyond the Famous Attractions

Manhattan ranked third with a score of 75.2.

New York’s appeal is different from that of Honolulu and Miami. Instead of beaches and tropical weather, Manhattan attracts visitors who want to experience one of the world’s most recognisable urban environments.

A house sit can offer a different perspective on a city usually experienced through crowded hotels, tourist attractions and tightly scheduled sightseeing.

The attraction of everyday New York

Many visitors arrive in New York with familiar places on their itineraries: Times Square, Central Park, the Empire State Building, Broadway and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

These attractions remain important, but they are only one part of the city’s identity.

Staying in a residential neighbourhood may allow travelers to discover:

  • Local bakeries and independent coffee shops.
  • Neighbourhood supermarkets and farmers’ markets.
  • Small restaurants and family-owned businesses.
  • Parks and public spaces used by residents.
  • Community events and local cultural activities.

The experience can be especially appealing to repeat visitors who have already seen the major landmarks and want to explore the city at a slower pace.

Why accommodation costs matter

New York is one of the most expensive major travel destinations in the United States.

According to New York City Tourism + Conventions, the city welcomed approximately 65 million visitors in 2025. Tourism generated $84.7 billion in total economic impact, including $55.6 billion in direct visitor spending.

The city’s hotel industry also remained busy. Average hotel occupancy reached 84.2% in 2025, while the average daily hotel rate was $334, a 5% increase over 2024.

These figures help explain why alternative accommodation arrangements are attracting attention.

A house sit may allow a traveler to spend more time in New York without paying the full cost of a hotel room. It can also provide access to a kitchen, laundry facilities and a residential setting.

However, house-sitting opportunities are competitive. TrustedHousesitters reported that 85% of Manhattan listings reached the five-application limit within seven days.

That means travelers should not assume that a suitable listing will be easy to secure.

4. Brooklyn: A Different Side of New York

Brooklyn ranked among the leading house-sitting destinations, offering a different experience from Manhattan.

The borough is known for its diverse neighbourhoods, independent businesses, parks, restaurants and creative communities.

It can be particularly attractive to travelers who want to experience New York without spending all their time in the busiest parts of Manhattan.

Neighbourhoods such as Williamsburg, Park Slope, Brooklyn Heights, Greenpoint and Prospect Heights each offer different atmospheres.

For example, Brooklyn Heights is known for its historic streets and waterfront views, while Williamsburg has a strong reputation for restaurants, music and creative businesses.

Park Slope offers a more residential environment, with tree-lined streets and access to Prospect Park.

One particularly interesting finding from the TrustedHousesitters report is that Brooklyn had the highest repeat-sitter share among the leading experience destinations, at 39.6%.

This suggests that a meaningful proportion of sitters who visit Brooklyn return for another opportunity.

Repeat behavior is worth noting because it may indicate that travelers value the experience beyond simply securing a convenient place to stay.

5. Fort Lauderdale: Florida’s More Relaxed Coastal Alternative

Fort Lauderdale completed the five leading destinations highlighted in the New York Post report.

Located north of Miami, the city offers beaches, waterways, restaurants and a somewhat different atmosphere from its larger neighbour.

Fort Lauderdale is often associated with boating, waterfront living and its extensive network of canals. It also provides access to South Florida’s wider attractions.

Visitors can explore:

  • Fort Lauderdale Beach.
  • Las Olas Boulevard.
  • The Riverwalk arts and entertainment district.
  • Bonnet House Museum & Gardens.
  • Local waterways and boating activities.

For travelers who enjoy warm weather but prefer a different pace from Miami, Fort Lauderdale may be worth considering.

Its position also makes it a potential base for exploring parts of South Florida, although visitors should account for travel distances and transport costs.

The TrustedHousesitters study reported an average annual temperature of 76.9°F for Fort Lauderdale, placing it among the warmest destinations in its comparison.

Like Miami, however, it is not automatically a budget destination. The same report placed its overall price level approximately 14.2% above the US average.

What Exactly Is House-Sitting Travel?

House-sitting is an arrangement in which a homeowner allows another person to stay in their property while they are away.

In exchange, the sitter usually takes responsibility for agreed tasks, most commonly caring for pets and maintaining basic household routines.

These responsibilities can include:

  • Feeding dogs, cats or other animals.
  • Walking dogs according to the owner’s instructions.
  • Giving pets prescribed medication where agreed and appropriate.
  • Cleaning litter trays or other pet areas.
  • Watering plants.
  • Collecting mail and accepting deliveries.
  • Keeping the property secure.
  • Informing the homeowner about problems or emergencies.

Some arrangements involve only a few days, while others last several weeks or longer.

The concept is particularly attractive to travelers who enjoy animals and are comfortable taking responsibility for someone else’s home.

Is house-sitting free?

House-sitting is often described as a way to obtain free accommodation, but that description needs qualification.

Many arrangements operate as an exchange rather than a paid service: the homeowner receives pet and household care, while the sitter receives a place to stay.

However, travelers may need to pay membership fees to access a platform, along with flights, transport, food, travel insurance and personal expenses.

Some house-sitting arrangements are also private agreements rather than platform-based exchanges.

The most important thing is to understand the exact terms before accepting an opportunity. A free place to stay can still involve significant responsibilities and expenses.

The Rise of Slow Travel and Living Like a Local

The popularity of house-sitting fits into the wider idea of slow travel.

Traditional holidays often involve fitting as many attractions as possible into a limited number of days. Travelers may visit several cities in a week, stay in centrally located hotels and spend much of their time moving between tourist attractions.

Slow travel takes a different approach.

Rather than focusing on how many places can be visited, it places greater emphasis on the quality of the experience.

A visitor might spend two weeks in one neighbourhood instead of visiting four cities in the same period. They may cook some meals, use public transportation, visit local businesses and develop a better understanding of everyday life.

There are several reasons this approach appeals to modern travelers.

More meaningful cultural experiences: Spending additional time in one location can create opportunities to understand local customs, food traditions and neighbourhood life.

Less pressure to rush: Travelers can enjoy a destination without constantly checking the clock or following a packed itinerary.

Potential accommodation savings: House-sitting may reduce one of the largest expenses associated with longer holidays.

Greater connection with animals: People who enjoy pets may find caring for them a rewarding part of the travel experience.

A different relationship with a destination: Returning to the same café or walking the same neighbourhood streets can make a visitor feel more connected to a place.

Nevertheless, slow travel is not automatically sustainable. Longer stays can still create pressure on housing, resources and local infrastructure, particularly when visitors use residential properties in ways that affect the availability of homes for residents.

The Hidden Challenges of House-Sitting

The idea of staying in an attractive home while exploring a popular destination sounds appealing. But house-sitting is not suitable for everyone.

It requires trust, preparation and a willingness to accept responsibilities that may influence the entire holiday.

1. Pet care is a genuine responsibility

A house sitter is not simply receiving accommodation.

Pets may need regular feeding, exercise, medication and attention. Some animals have medical conditions or behavioural issues that require special care.

A sitter who wants complete freedom to spend long days sightseeing may find the arrangement difficult.

2. Listings can be highly competitive

The TrustedHousesitters figures show that demand can be intense in popular locations.

When a listing receives multiple applications within a few days, homeowners have the opportunity to choose among several candidates.

New sitters may find it harder to compete against people with strong reviews and previous experience.

Building a credible profile, providing references and communicating clearly can improve the chances of being selected.

3. Travel plans may need to remain flexible

House-sitting dates are determined by the homeowner’s travel schedule.

The arrangement may not match a traveler’s ideal departure or return dates. A sitter may also need to arrive early enough to receive instructions and meet the animals.

Last-minute cancellations or changes can create additional complications.

4. Insurance and emergency arrangements matter

Travelers should not assume that a house-sitting platform automatically provides comprehensive insurance.

TrustedHousesitters states that homeowners should maintain appropriate home and pet-related insurance, while sitters should consider suitable travel and health insurance for their own circumstances.

The platform also explains that the exact protections available depend on membership arrangements.

Before accepting a sit, both parties should clarify responsibility for veterinary expenses, household damage, emergencies and unexpected cancellations.

5. House-sitting may not suit every travel style

People who want to spend most of their time outside the home may struggle with pet-care obligations.

Some homeowners expect sitters to follow strict routines, remain at the property for significant portions of the day or avoid leaving pets alone for long periods.

Travelers should discuss these expectations before committing.

Can House-Sitting Help Reduce Overtourism?

House-sitting may encourage visitors to explore areas beyond major tourist districts.

Instead of staying exclusively in central hotels, travelers may spend time in residential neighbourhoods, visit local shops and use nearby parks and services.

This can distribute visitor spending across a wider area.

However, it would be inaccurate to claim that house-sitting automatically solves overtourism.

Residential accommodation can create its own problems if properties are increasingly converted into visitor accommodation or if visitors place additional pressure on neighbourhood infrastructure.

The effect depends on the type of arrangement, local housing conditions and whether the property would otherwise remain available to residents.

A responsible approach should involve respecting local rules, supporting independent businesses, avoiding disruptive behaviour and understanding the concerns of residents.

Authenticity is not simply about finding places that tourists have not discovered. It is about engaging with a community without treating it as a backdrop for personal entertainment.

A Viral Example: When House-Sitting Becomes a Lifestyle

The New York Post report also highlighted Alanna Parish, a New Yorker who attracted attention on social media after describing how she lives in other people’s homes through house-sitting arrangements.

Rather than maintaining a conventional rental home, Parish explained that she coordinates consecutive house sits so that one arrangement ends around the time another begins.

Her experience illustrates how house-sitting can move beyond a short holiday arrangement and become a lifestyle choice.

However, this approach requires considerable organisation.

A person relying on house-sitting as a primary accommodation strategy must continually find suitable opportunities, maintain good relationships with homeowners, manage gaps between bookings and remain prepared for cancellations.

It is also important to distinguish between a personal lifestyle experiment and a practical option for the average traveler.

Most people will find occasional house-sitting easier to manage than depending on it as their permanent housing solution.

How to Find and Secure a House-Sitting Opportunity

Travelers interested in trying this style of accommodation should prepare before applying.

Build a trustworthy profile. Explain your experience with animals, household responsibilities and previous stays. References can help homeowners feel more comfortable.

Apply early. Popular destinations can attract many applicants. Starting the search well before the intended travel dates gives you more opportunities.

Be specific about your experience. Caring for a senior dog, administering medication or looking after several cats requires different skills from simply feeding a healthy adult pet.

Read the listing carefully. Check the location, dates, pet-care responsibilities, household rules and expectations about time spent at home.

Arrange a conversation with the homeowner. A video call can help both sides discuss expectations and determine whether the arrangement is suitable.

Prepare a written agreement. Confirm emergency contacts, veterinary arrangements, household access, responsibilities and what happens if plans change.

Have a backup plan. Even a well-organised arrangement can be disrupted by unexpected circumstances. Keep enough money available for alternative accommodation and transport if necessary.

Are There Alternatives to House-Sitting?

Travelers who like the idea of living more locally but do not want pet-care responsibilities have several alternatives.

Home exchanges

Home exchange arrangements allow two households to swap accommodation, either simultaneously or at different times.

They can be useful for people who own or rent suitable homes and want to avoid conventional accommodation costs.

Serviced apartments

Serviced apartments offer kitchens, laundry facilities and more space than many hotel rooms. They are particularly suitable for longer stays.

Guesthouses and locally owned accommodation

Independent guesthouses can provide a more personal experience than large international hotel chains.

Homestays

A homestay allows visitors to stay with a local host or family. It can offer valuable opportunities to learn about local food, customs and daily routines.

Longer hotel stays

Some hotels and accommodation providers offer discounted rates for extended bookings. Travelers should compare these options against house-sitting before making a decision.

The best choice depends on budget, flexibility, personal interests and the amount of responsibility a traveler is willing to accept.

The Future of Travel: From Collecting Destinations to Experiencing Places

The growing interest in house-sitting suggests that at least some travelers are reconsidering what makes a holiday worthwhile.

For decades, travel marketing has encouraged people to collect experiences: famous landmarks, luxury hotels, bucket-list destinations and photographs of iconic attractions.

Those experiences still matter. But an increasing number of travelers are also interested in something less spectacular and more personal.

They want to discover the neighbourhood bakery, understand local food traditions, walk through a park with residents and spend enough time in a destination to appreciate its character.

House-sitting offers one way to achieve that experience, particularly for people who enjoy animals and have flexible schedules.

Honolulu, Miami, Manhattan, Brooklyn and Fort Lauderdale each provide a different version of this lifestyle. One offers island routines, another combines Caribbean and Latin American influences, while New York’s neighbourhoods offer a constantly changing urban experience.

The rankings should not be mistaken for a definitive list of America’s most authentic destinations. They reflect demand among users of one house-sitting platform. Still, they reveal an interesting shift in how some people want to travel.

The future of tourism may not be about abandoning hotels or avoiding famous attractions. It may simply involve giving travelers more ways to experience destinations at a human pace.

Conclusion: The Best Travel Experience May Feel Less Like a Holiday

The growing interest in house-sitting reveals that travelers are looking for more than a convenient bed and a list of attractions.

For some, the appeal is financial. For others, it is the opportunity to spend more time in a destination, care for animals or experience neighbourhood life beyond the usual tourist circuit.

Honolulu’s position at the top of the TrustedHousesitters ranking, followed by Miami and New York, demonstrates the strong appeal of warm-weather destinations and major urban centres among the platform’s members.

But the real lesson is broader than the rankings.

Travel becomes more meaningful when visitors approach a destination with curiosity, patience and respect. Staying in a residential neighbourhood does not automatically make someone a local, and a house-sitting arrangement is not a substitute for responsible tourism.

The best experiences come from understanding the place, supporting its communities and recognising that a destination is first and foremost somebody else’s home.

Would you spend your next holiday looking after someone’s pet in exchange for a place to stay? Or would you rather keep the freedom and convenience of a traditional hotel?


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What are the most popular US destinations for house-sitting travelers in 2026?

According to TrustedHousesitters’ 2026 experience ranking, Honolulu, Hawaii, came first with a score of 79.8 out of 100. Miami ranked second with 76.9, followed by Manhattan with 75.2. Brooklyn and Fort Lauderdale also featured among the leading destinations.

2. What is house-sitting, and how does it work?

House-sitting is an arrangement in which a person stays in someone else’s home while the owner is away. The sitter typically looks after pets, maintains basic household routines and helps keep the property secure. In exchange, the sitter receives accommodation, usually without paying a conventional nightly rental fee.

3. Is house-sitting a good way to travel on a budget?

It can reduce accommodation costs, particularly in expensive destinations such as Honolulu, Miami and New York. However, travelers still need to pay for transport, food, insurance, platform memberships where applicable and personal activities. Pet-care responsibilities can also limit travel flexibility.

4. Is house-sitting safe for travelers and homeowners?

It can be a positive arrangement when both parties check references, communicate clearly and agree on responsibilities in advance. Homeowners should confirm insurance and veterinary arrangements, while sitters should consider suitable travel and health insurance. A written agreement and emergency contact information are also important.

5. Why are travelers increasingly interested in authentic local experiences?

Many travelers want to spend more time understanding a destination rather than simply visiting famous landmarks. Longer stays, neighbourhood exploration, local food, cultural activities and everyday routines can provide a deeper connection with a place. House-sitting is one way to experience this style of travel, although it is not the only option.

Sources New York Post

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top